Copier Lease vs. Managed Print Services (MPS): What’s the Difference and Which One Saves More?
Bottom line up front
A copier lease is mainly a financing agreement for the hardware. Managed Print Services (MPS) is a service program that manages your entire printing environment, usually including supplies, service, monitoring, and cost controls.
Which saves more?
- Lease-only usually costs less short-term if you print lightly and can manage supplies and support internally.
- MPS usually saves more long-term if you have multiple devices, unpredictable toner ordering, downtime issues, or no one wants to own printer problems.
If your office is spending time chasing toner, dealing with jams, arguing about who printed what, or you have more than a couple devices, MPS is often the better financial decision.
Why people confuse these
Because many vendors bundle them together and call it “a lease.”
In reality, there are two separate questions:
- How are you paying for the copier(s)? (lease, buy, rent)
- How are you supporting and controlling printing? (break/fix, service agreement, or MPS)
Understanding that split is the fastest way to compare quotes without getting fooled.
What a copier lease is (plain English)
A copier lease is a contract, usually with a leasing company, that lets you spread the cost of a copier over time.
What a lease typically covers
- The copier hardware financing
- A fixed monthly payment for the term (often 36–60 months)
- End-of-lease options depending on the lease type (FMV vs $1 buyout)
What a lease usually does not cover
- Toner and supplies (unless bundled separately)
- Service calls, parts, and labor (unless you also have a service agreement)
- Managing printers across the office
- Print policies, user controls, reporting, and optimization
A lease is how you pay for the box. It is not a strategy for printing.
What Managed Print Services (MPS) is
Managed Print Services (MPS) is a program where a provider manages your print environment so you get predictable costs and less chaos.
What MPS commonly includes
- Proactive monitoring of toner levels, device health, and error states
- Automatic toner fulfillment before you run out
- Service and maintenance (parts and labor)
- Fleet standardization so you are not supporting 10 different printer models
- Usage reporting (who prints, how much, where the money is going)
- Rules and controls to reduce waste (duplex default, secure print, quotas)
- Device right-sizing so you are not paying for more machine than you need
In short: MPS is the operating system for printing.
The big differences that impact cost
1. Cost structure and predictability
Lease-only: predictable hardware payment, unpredictable supplies and service.
MPS: more predictable overall spend because supplies and service are usually built in.
2. Who does the work
Lease-only: your office manager or IT team becomes the print department.
MPS: the provider owns toner, support, and uptime.
3. Waste and sprawl
Lease-only: printer sprawl happens quietly. People buy random printers, expenses spread across credit cards, downtime increases.
MPS: programs reduce device count, reduce models, and reduce waste.
4. Visibility
Lease-only: most companies cannot answer basic questions like “what are we spending on printing each month?”
MPS: reporting and device monitoring make costs visible.
Which one saves more? Real-world scenarios
Scenario A: One copier, low print volume, stable needs
If you have:
- One main copier
- Low print volume
- A team that rarely prints
- No compliance or security concerns tied to printing
A lease + basic service plan often costs less than full MPS.
Scenario B: Multiple printers, multiple departments, constant toner drama
If you have:
- Several printers and one copier
- Different models and brands
- People buying toner online in emergencies
- Downtime that disrupts billing, invoicing, or patient intake
MPS usually saves more, even if the monthly price looks higher, because it eliminates:
- Rush toner purchases
- Wasted supplies
- Time spent troubleshooting
- “Death by a thousand receipts” in accounting
Scenario C: Regulated industries or confidential documents
If you have:
- Sensitive documents
- Audit requirements
- Concerns about staff printing and leaving papers in trays
MPS often wins because it supports:
- Secure print release
- User authentication
- Reporting and accountability
The hidden costs most companies forget to count
When businesses say they “save money” without MPS, they often forget to count:
- Staff time spent troubleshooting printers and scanners
- IT time spent supporting random devices and drivers
- Emergency toner purchases at retail prices
- Waste from single-sided printing and abandoned print jobs
- Downtime when invoices, shipping labels, or intake forms stop printing
- Vendor sprawl in accounting (multiple toner vendors and receipts)
Even if you never calculate these formally, they show up in payroll, productivity, and frustration.
How to tell which option fits your office (quick checklist)
You are a better fit for Managed Print Services if any of these are true:
- You have 3+ devices across the office
- Toner runs out unexpectedly more than once a quarter
- Your team complains about printing or scanning regularly
- Accounting wants fewer vendors and cleaner billing
- You want reporting, controls, and fewer surprise costs
You are a better fit for lease-only + service plan if:
- You have 1–2 devices
- Your printing is light and consistent
- You do not need usage reporting or controls
- Someone internally can manage toner and basic issues
A simple way to compare quotes without getting tricked
When reviewing proposals, separate the numbers into three buckets:
- Hardware payment (lease or purchase)
- Service and maintenance (parts, labor, response times)
- Supplies and print cost (toner, drums, overages, replenishment)
If a vendor shows you only one monthly number, ask for the breakdown. Without it, you cannot compare quotes accurately.
FAQ
Is MPS only for large companies?
No. Small businesses often benefit when they have multiple printers, multiple locations, or heavy scanning and printing workflows.
Can MPS include copiers and printers?
Yes. Good MPS programs manage the entire fleet, not just one copier.
Will MPS force us to replace all our printers?
Not usually. Many programs start by monitoring what you already have, then phase out the worst devices over time.
Does MPS lock you into long contracts?
Sometimes. Some programs align with a lease term, while others offer more flexible agreements. Always ask about term length and exit options before signing.
Next step
If you are unsure which option you currently have, start with one simple question:
“Do we want to finance a copier, or do we want someone to own printing problems and control costs?”
If you want, we can run a quick assessment of your current printer fleet and show you which option is likely to cost less based on your real usage.
NEED A QUOTE NOW?
You'll Get a Real Quote in Under 2 Minutes!